IndexedDB Disposition of Comments

During its Last Call phases, the following changes were made to the IndexedDB specification based on public review and implementor feedback.

Resolutions and Responses

WebApps WG Resolutions

The Resolution column refers to the resolution to the issue, as determined by the working group, and may contain the following values:

agree	compromise	disagree

Commenter Responses

The Staisfaction column refers to the response of the person(s) reporting the issue to the working group decision, and may contain the following values:

satisfied	no response	not satisfied

Disposition of Comments:

Bug ID or Issue Number	Title of Issue or Bug	Date commented or date bug opened	Commenter or person opening bug	Status	Resolution	Satisfaction
Bug 16441	Spec should note that onsuccess shouldn’t be used for writes.	2012-03-19	Yonathan Randolph	New	TBD	TBD
Bug 16467	[IndexedDB] [editorial] remove spurious IDBVersionChangeRequest-sentence	2012-03-21	Odin Hørthe Omdal	New	TBD	TBD
Bug 16513	Use WebIDL enum for IDBDatabase.transaction's mode argument	2012-03-25	Ms2ger	New	TBD	TBD
Bug 16596	Clarify how upgradeneeded works in the .open function	2012-04-01	Jonas Sicking	New	TBD	TBD
Bug 16653	IndexedDB: Define overloads for IDBDatabase.transaction()	2012-04-06	Joshua Bell	New	TBD	TBD
Bug 17032	IndexedDB: Editorial - use of phrase "explicit key" is confusing	2012-05-10	Joshua Bell	New	TBD	TBD
Bug 17198	Remove mention of IDBVersionChangeRequest	2012-05-25	Jonas Sicking	New	TBD	TBD
Bug 17236	Ambiguity in IDBTransaction.error around 'done' state	2012-05-29	Alec Flett	New	TBD	TBD
Bug 17253	[IndexedDB] IDL typo	2012-05-30	Odin Hørthe Omdal	New	TBD	TBD
Bug 17276	Step 8 in versionchange transaction algorithm is wrong.	2012-05-31	Jonas Sicking	New	TBD	TBD
Bug 17303	Fix editorial issues from Tobie	2012-06-04	Jonas Sicking, for Tobie Langel	New	TBD	TBD
Bug 17538	[IndexedDB] Remove error clauses for invalid index keys	2012-06-18	Joshua Bell	New	TBD	TBD
Bug 17609	[IndexedDB] Events fired after transaction abort should not set active flag	2012-06-26*	Joshua Bell	New	TBD	TBD
Bug 17643	What should transaction.error be set to if a error handler throws an exception	2012-06-28*	Jonas Sicking	New	TBD	TBD
Bug 17645	Define more precisely what the "origin" of the IDBEnvironment is	2012-06-29*	Jonas Sicking	New	TBD	TBD
Bug 17649	Address WebIDL comments from Kyle Huey	2012-06-29	Jonas Sicking, for Kyle Huey	New	TBD	TBD
Bug 17650	Make createIndex throw InvalidAccessError instead of NotSupportedError	2012-06-29*	Jonas Sicking	New	TBD	TBD
Bug 17657	Empty arrays shouldn't be valid KeyPaths	2012-06-30*	Jonas Sicking	New	TBD	TBD
Bug 17681	[IndexedDB] Operations that raise multiple exceptions types should define order	2012-07-03*	Joshua Bell	New	TBD	TBD
Bug 17702	[IndexedDB editorial] IDBIndex.getKey should tell what it's doing	2012-07-05*	Odin Hørthe Omdal	New	TBD	TBD

*Bugs and comments filed after 21 June 2012 occur after the Last Call deadline.

Eliot Graff (eliotgra@microsoft.com)